Selena's
Cake Pops 
&
 More
859-221-6988
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Cakes & Cup Cakes
  • Cake Pops & More
  • Party Packages
  • Cookies
  • old Fashion Pies
  • Homemade Candies
  • Homemade Fudge
  • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
  • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
  • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
  • "Adults Only" Novelty
  • Chocolate Dipped Fruits
  • More
    • Home
    • Contact
    • Cakes & Cup Cakes
    • Cake Pops & More
    • Party Packages
    • Cookies
    • old Fashion Pies
    • Homemade Candies
    • Homemade Fudge
    • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
    • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
    • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
    • "Adults Only" Novelty
    • Chocolate Dipped Fruits
Selena's
Cake Pops 
&
 More
859-221-6988
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Cakes & Cup Cakes
  • Cake Pops & More
  • Party Packages
  • Cookies
  • old Fashion Pies
  • Homemade Candies
  • Homemade Fudge
  • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
  • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
  • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
  • "Adults Only" Novelty
  • Chocolate Dipped Fruits

Home Style Pies

Made from momma's cook book, all pies come in 9"

Older Than TIme Pecan Pie

$30.00

In a buttery crust, some of the sweetes suryps know to all kind. Toped and stuffed with toasted peacans this pie is sure to send send your taste buds back to the gold old days.

Coconut Supreme

$30.00

Buttery pie crust, filled with the bursting flavors of coconut, and vanilla cream. Topped with fluffy cream icing and toasted coconut.

Chocolate Meringue Pie

$30.00

A floured pie crust, filled with silky smooth chocolate pie filling, covered in meringue icing. 

Pumpkin Cream Pie

$30.00

New To Menu - Fall is back and so are our fall favorites. Nothing better for the Holidays. Our Pumpkin cream pie is smooth delight, full of all those warm Holiday spices, whipped pumpkin and cream cheese filling. Topped with our homemade cream cheese icing . Poured into a holiday spice gram crust. 

Key Lime Time

$30.00

Get that freshness of summer with our sweet and bitter Key Lime Pie. topped with a golden Meringue Icing.

Peanut Butter Pie

$30.00

Try out our rich creamy peanut butter pie, loaded in sweet creamy flavor with your choice of a homemade pie crust or rich chocolate Oreo Crust, topped in sweet whipped cream, drizzled in chocolate and peanut butter drizzle. 

Chocolate Oreo Pie

$30.00

Try this delightful layered Chocolate Oreo Pie, with a crisp oreo crust.  Topped with a whippy, cool topping and dusted in Oreo crums.

Derby Pie

$30.00

A mixture of southren ingreidents, Drizzled in simi sweet chocolate, and loaded with peacns for all our nut lovers.

Photo Gallery


    Copyright © 2025 Making Tasty Wishes Come True! - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions