Selena's
Cake Pops 
&
 More
859-221-6988
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Cakes & Cup Cakes
  • Cake Pops & More
  • Party Packages
  • Cookies
  • old Fashion Pies
  • Homemade Candies
  • Homemade Fudge
  • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
  • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
  • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
  • "Adults Only" Novelty
  • Chocolate Dipped Fruits
  • More
    • Home
    • Contact
    • Cakes & Cup Cakes
    • Cake Pops & More
    • Party Packages
    • Cookies
    • old Fashion Pies
    • Homemade Candies
    • Homemade Fudge
    • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
    • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
    • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
    • "Adults Only" Novelty
    • Chocolate Dipped Fruits
Selena's
Cake Pops 
&
 More
859-221-6988
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Cakes & Cup Cakes
  • Cake Pops & More
  • Party Packages
  • Cookies
  • old Fashion Pies
  • Homemade Candies
  • Homemade Fudge
  • Gift Boxes & Gift Sets
  • Seasonal Occasion Cakes
  • Cocoa & Coffee Bombs
  • "Adults Only" Novelty
  • Chocolate Dipped Fruits

Custom Cakes For All Occasions

Custom Cakes

Make Any Combination of your favorite flavors to any one cake. 1 - pick your cake. 2- pick your icing. 3- picking your filling if you choose one. All cake servings are based on a Bakers Wedding Cake Slice. A Wedding Cake Slice is a 1" square slice. If you are ordering for a party, the slices are cut lager so the cake will serve less.

Cake Flavors

  • Almond
  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Italian Cream (fluffy vanilla cake with creamy whip to it stuff with toasted pecans and coconut)
  • Lemon Raspberry 
  • Strawberry Lemonade 
  • Red Velvet 
  • Orange Cream 
  • Carrot Cake 
  • Pineapple
  • Butter Peacan 
  • Coffee 
  • Cookies & Cream 
  • Snicker Doodle 
  • Pumpkin Cream Spice 
  • Funfetti 
  • Peanut Butter Fudge 
  • Spice Cake
  • Yellow Cake 
  • Banana Cream
  • Salted Carmel
  • Coconut Cream
  • Carrot Cake (contains pecans and raisins)
  • Hawiian 
  • Blueberry Cream
  • Tres Lesches (offered in vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry)


Icing Flavors

  • Cream Cheese (not suggested for tiered cakes)
  • snicker doodle 
  •  Vanilla
  •  Almond
  • Chocolate
  •  Strawberry
  • Oreo 
  • Orange Cream
  • Sweet Maple 

Cake Fillings Additional $10 per tier.

  • Cherry Glaze 
  • Lemon curd 
  • Strawberry (Freshly diced strawberries with glaze.)
  • Pineapple
  • Oreo Cream
  • Peanut Butter
  • Apple filling 
  • Raspberry 
  • Fresh fruits (strawberries, blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, banana, or peaches) 
  • Sneakers 
  • Heath 
  • Butter Finger 
  • Carmel 
  • Whipped Fudge
  • Peppermint Crumble 

Cake Sample Box

$50.00

A total of 6 - 4inch round samples, with your choice of flavors. 


Letter & Number Cakes

$75.00 1 Letter or Number $150.00 2 letters or Numbers

Size: 12 inches' 

Serves: up to 18

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

Smash Cakes

$65.00

Serves: up to 12 

Includes one flavor of cake and one flavor of icing. 

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc.   

6" Cakes

$80.00 to $125

.   Serves: up to 12 

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

8" round

$95.00 to $150

Serves: up to 20

   *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

10" round

$130.00 to $180

Serves: up to 25

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

12" round

$160.00 to $250

Serves: up to 40

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

   

14" round

$260.00 to $350

Serves: up to 75

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

  

2 tier 8" & 6"

$150 to $250

Serves: up to 22 

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

2 tier 10" & 8"

$170 to $275

Serves: up to 45

   *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

3 tier 6", 8", & 10"

$260 to $700

Serves: up to 78

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

4 tier cake 6",8", 10", & 12"

$360 to $1500

Serves:  100

 *Additional fees may apply for special request such as additional decorating, fillings, and etc. 

sheet cake

1/4 $75.00 1/2 $110.00

1/4 Serves: up to 20 Double Layered

1/2 Serves up to 50. Double Layered


Wedding CAKES fOR ANY sEASON

    Childrens birthday Cakes

      Birthday Cakes

        Sports cakes

          Smash CAkes & Small CakE Items

            Scary Birthday Cakes

              heart cakes

                sheet Cakes

                  Letter and Number Cakes

                    Burn Cakes

                      bABY sHOWER

                        Old Fashion Cakes

                          Menu / Price List

                          Old Fashion Cakes - All Come In A 10" Cake

                          Back Yard Vanilla

                          $65.00

                          Our 10" Back Yard Vanilla cake is packed with the rich flavor of vanilla. It's not your typical vanilla cake. each bite is supper moist. Covered in sweet vanilla butter cream icing. 

                          Country Boys German Cake

                          $65.00

                          Chocolate can be so much more, when the sweet taste of caramelized German icing is added, so packed full of flavors such as roasted pecans,  coconut, sweet brown sugar, and that rich cream. A 10" cake have your family coming back for more.  

                          Coconut Cream

                          $65.00

                          A combination of our rich vanilla cake, with centered and cover toasted coconut icing, and covered with rich toasted coconuts, then topped with cherries. Back to the way grandma would make it.

                          Pine Apple Upside Down

                          $65.00

                          Sure to remind you of the Holliday Table!  Made with moist yellow cake, glazed in a rich brown sugar syrup, stuffed with fresh Hawaiian pineapples, and toped with bright red cherries.   

                          Momma's Strawberry Jam Cake

                          $65.00

                          Made with the sweetness of Amish strawberry jams, toasted pecans, raisins, and seasonal spice. Topped with brown sugar strawberry glaze and toasted pecans.

                          Momma's Blackberry Jam Cake

                          $65.00

                          Packed full of sweet Holliday flavors, Amish blackberry jam, roasted walnuts, raisins, and the settle aroma of all the seasonings such as nutmeg, cloves, ginger, and cinnamon. Topped in a caramel glaze, covered in toasted walnuts.  

                          Strawberry Patch

                          $65.00

                          Right into the sweet smells of summer!  Strawberry Patch is a rich moist strawberry cake, in two layers with the center stuffed with fresh ripe strawberries, covered in sweet strawberry butter cream icing. 

                          Lemon

                          $65.00

                          Lemon says it all. Made with freshly squeezed lemon juice,  and sweet brown sugars, covered in a split mixture of lemon and vanilla cream frosting and topped with cherries. 

                          Snicker Doodle

                          $65.00

                          Remember those sweet little snicker doodle cookies grandma use to make? Then you'll love this cake! Sweet, moist, popping cinnamon flavors, covered in a sweet snicker doodle cream cheese icing .

                          Orange Dream Sickle

                          $65.00

                          Noting like a dream sickle.  our richly moist vanilla cake creamed together with that citrussy fresh squeezed oranges to fill it full of that flavored goodness. Covered in sweet vanilla butter cream icing. 

                          Chocolate Supreme

                          $65.00

                          Starting with a home made chocolate ganache, whipped in to the finest cake mix and and creams.

                          Covered in a rich creamy chocolate butter cream. 

                          Key Lime Cream

                          $65.00

                          New To Menu- Try out this tarty sweet,  moist creamy pack in the tarty flavors of our delightful Key Lime Cake, covered in Key Lime Butter Cream, with our richly toasted gram sprinkle. 

                          Add a footnote if this applies to your business

                          Cup Cakes

                            Menu / Price List

                            Add a description about this category

                            Cup Cakes

                            $30.00

                            1 dozen regular sized - basic cup cakes is done in your choice of colors , and topped with your choice of sprinkles, nuts, or fruit.

                            Basic Mini Cup Cakes

                            $20.00

                            1 dozen mini sized - basic cup cakes is done in your choice of colors , and topped with your choice of sprinkles, nuts, or fruit.

                            Cakes In Cup or Jar

                            $48.00

                            1 dozen - Try our 16 oz cakes in a cup load with flavor and toppings 

                            Fancy Cup Cakes

                            $48.00

                            1 dozen regular sized - Fancy cup cakes are made with your theme and colors with custom flowers, characters, logos, and more.

                            Add a footnote if this applies to your business

                            Reviews

                            Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth with Making Tasty Wishes Come True!


                              Copyright © 2025 Making Tasty Wishes Come True! - All Rights Reserved.

                              Powered by

                              • Privacy Policy
                              • Terms and Conditions